Understanding Curves: Air Intake Exercise - What start/end order do I use Bridging Curves?
What is the reason that we select Dark Blue's edge and point before selecting Grey's edge in step 1?
What is the reason that we select Dark Blue's edge before selecting Grey's edge and point in step 2?
et cetera…
For what reason are the edges chosen in this manner? I want to understand why a single piece doesn't have all the Start selection. What is the best practice to making Bridging Curves? Is it similar to fastening a tire, tightening the nut across from one another in a star shape as if i'm evening out pressure?
I would really love if this part of the course was more clear on what effects my ordering of parameters will have, if any :).
Answers
-
That's one of those tools which has had lots of upgrades over the years, except for its associated help files.
A couple of prompts for your LLM of choice . . .
In Onshape - when was the 'Bridging Curve' introduced and what problems was it trying to solve?and
In Onshape - with 'Bridging Curves' does the order of edge or point selection affect the resulting shape of the curve?Here's Google's attempt at an explanation -
Unemployed Onshaper- Operating on European time - More of me here ➤➤ https://linktr.ee/Liam.G0 -
Ok. I've just spent an hour experimenting with 'Bridging Curves' because I realised I didn't fully understand them myself.
Edit: Specifically using the G3 continuity option.
My observations:
- VERY un-intuitive, especially those draggable white arrows, three for each start and end point
- at the very least, those arrows need to be color-coded in some way
- completely different initial results depending on selection order
- the tool 'should' be smart enough to detect which 'end' of an edge is selected in order to suggest a better first guess
A useful playground I made - have a go at adding the remaining three Bridging Curves with G3 continuity - https://cad.onshape.com/documents/c5c668a888cca9e5718a94c5/w/937dc1b803a314c1b486d6c8/e/d60c90a4a8d8edce42af1560?renderMode=0&uiState=69e9fbc29e20224e14c17fe4
Unemployed Onshaper- Operating on European time - More of me here ➤➤ https://linktr.ee/Liam.G1 -
I love bridging curves, and I also think the standard help content is fairly straightforward.
- You can also select all lines and points before starting a new bridging curve
- The sequence of where you start doesn’t matter in my experience.
- Colored arrows… mmm… not really needed in my opinion – just zoom in a bit:)
1 -
Standard help is 'far' from complete IMHO. There is only a single video that is many years old and it doesn't demonstrate any of the newer options that the tool now contains.
Also, the direction changing buttons - indicated below - are not mentioned anywhere, and they make a huge difference, which I only 'accidentally' discovered.
Unemployed Onshaper- Operating on European time - More of me here ➤➤ https://linktr.ee/Liam.G0 -
Ok, but by the time you reach the point in your Onshape learning path where you start using bridges, you should already have seen and used the same orientation‑switching arrows before, for example in extrudes, right?
But I’m probably a bit biased toward arrows… and I’m probably holding some kind of record for the highest number of different arrows in a single feature with my new custom feature, hehe:)
2 -
uhm…. I think I need to explore that custom feature.
1 -
Custom feature which is just a set of vertexes each with their own arrows to form a mesh ("I am the king of arrows!") hehehe
0
