Home› Using Onshape

Welcome to the Onshape forum! Ask questions and join in the discussions about everything Onshape.

First time visiting? Here are some places to start:
  1. Looking for a certain topic? Check out the categories filter or use Search (upper right).
  2. Need support? Ask a question to our Community Support category.
  3. Please submit support tickets for bugs but you can request improvements in the Product Feedback category.
  4. Be respectful, on topic and if you see a problem, Flag it.

If you would like to contact our Community Manager personally, feel free to send a private message or an email.

Options

Extrude in non-normal direction - workaround.

romeograhamromeograham Member, csevp Posts: 657 PRO
edited February 2019 in Using Onshape
Anyone that is coming from SolidWorks may be used to using the "extrude direction" capability in Extrude features: you can select a direction that is not normal to the sketch's plane for the extrude. 

I was trying to figure out how to do this in Onshape (but there isn't that exact feature).

I stumbled on a work-around, using a temporary body / sketch.

Turns out that an extrude feature will go in the direction normal to the first sketch / face selected. Then you can select a different sketch / face, and it will be extruded in the same direction as the normal of the first sketch:


Sketch 4 (on my "Line of Draw" plane) is selected first. Then Sketch 3 is selected. This is the body that I really want in my model. You can see the body extruded from Sketch 3 goes in the direction I'd like, but originates from a different plane.

This could save using a sweep or other combination of features to achieve the correct geometry. Combined with a draft in the Extrude, it reduces the number of features required for some types of geometry where the Line of Draw is not necessarily normal to planes / faces in the model.

For the extra seed extruded body, you would have to delete it after this feature. For Subtract or Intersect extrudes, the "seed" body is not created, and doesn't have to be eliminated after you're done.

Does anyone have a FeatureScript that allows an "extrude in direction" option?

I created an IR a while ago, but now can't find it....

Thanks
Romeo

Comments

  • Options
    lanalana Onshape Employees Posts: 693
    Please try this one https://cad.onshape.com/documents/95b6b10616fa81d9419fcdd2/w/cc24386f808341a7df6eaf67/e/431b4ee0027a693d94189360

  • Options
    romeograhamromeograham Member, csevp Posts: 657 PRO
    @lana
    That's perfect! works just like I hoped.

    Why oh why is not part of the default Extrude command?

    Thanks!
  • Options
    MBartlett21MBartlett21 Member, OS Professional, Developers Posts: 2,034 EDU
    @romeo_graham392
    You can also use this feature (It has a thin-feature option as well)
    https://cad.onshape.com/documents/24819ddab7dc83c810eb8246
    mb - draftsman - also FS author: View FeatureScripts
    IR for AS/NZS 1100
  • Options
    romeograhamromeograham Member, csevp Posts: 657 PRO
    Thanks @MBartlett21. That's a great FS too!
  • Options
    Jake_RosenfeldJake_Rosenfeld Moderator, Onshape Employees, Developers Posts: 1,646
    @romeo_graham392

    To answer your question, we are always fighting an uphill battle of simplicity vs. robustness.  We haven't heard a lot of people asking for extrude direction selection, so it's not worth making the extrude command more complicated for a use case that people haven't expressed interest in.
    Jake Rosenfeld - Modeling Team
  • Options
    wouter_visserwouter_visser Member Posts: 14 ✭
    Strange that people haven't expressed interest - it's a killer feature for designing injection molded products. When adding a feature on a part that has to be injection-molded, it's really convenient to extrude it in the open/close-direction, which often is not normal to the part surface.
  • Options
    MBartlett21MBartlett21 Member, OS Professional, Developers Posts: 2,034 EDU
    @Jake_Rosenfeld
    If a direction selection is added to the extrude command, will we then be able to select non-planar faces to extrude and non-sketch edges?
    mb - draftsman - also FS author: View FeatureScripts
    IR for AS/NZS 1100
  • Options
    elifelif Onshape Employees Posts: 50
    All this can be achieved by sweep, all you need is a linear edge as the path which will act like the direction+length of extrude. 
    Team Lead, Part Studios
  • Options
    romeograhamromeograham Member, csevp Posts: 657 PRO
    One of the advantages "Extrude in Direction" is the ability to add draft as part of the extrude feature. While not useful in every situation - sometimes building the draft in is handy.
    A sweep wouldn't be able to do that without a separate feature.
  • Options
    elifelif Onshape Employees Posts: 50
    Agreed.
    Team Lead, Part Studios
  • Options
    bruce_williamsbruce_williams Member, Developers Posts: 842 PRO
    I use @MBartlett21 ExtrudeInDirection all the time. Thanks Morgan!  You can just pick a face, plane, or edge for direction.

    here is the closest IR I found - please vote!

    https://cad.onshape.com/documents/95b6b10616fa81d9419fcdd2/v/5e7ee41b4f8366b40b835f1b/e/c29448656f30372b1d04a5f7
    www.accuratepattern.com
  • Options
    brucebartlettbrucebartlett Member, OS Professional, Mentor, User Group Leader Posts: 2,137 PRO
    I've always wanted this in Onshape, it was a great tool to use in SW. I often think I wish I could just select and face and define a direction up to another face. 
    Engineer ı Product Designer ı Onshape Consulting Partner
    Twitter: @onshapetricks  & @babart1977   
  • Options
    ryan_mcgoldrick47ryan_mcgoldrick47 Member Posts: 93 ✭✭✭
    bumping this, saves a lot of time and unrequired sketches.
  • Options
    Jake_RosenfeldJake_Rosenfeld Moderator, Onshape Employees, Developers Posts: 1,646
    Voting on this IR is the best way to make your voice heard on this:
    https://forum.onshape.com/discussion/11235/option-to-extrude-along-vector
    Jake Rosenfeld - Modeling Team
  • Options
    ryan_mcgoldrick47ryan_mcgoldrick47 Member Posts: 93 ✭✭✭
    done
  • Options
    brucebartlettbrucebartlett Member, OS Professional, Mentor, User Group Leader Posts: 2,137 PRO
    done, looking forward to this. 
    Engineer ı Product Designer ı Onshape Consulting Partner
    Twitter: @onshapetricks  & @babart1977   
  • Options
    erik_st_gelaiserik_st_gelais Member Posts: 2 ✭
    I'm brand new to OnShape and I'm already looking for this feature. My very first drawing, designing a step stool. I see the above comment regarding simplicity vs robustness, and I certainly appreciate how easy it is to learn the basics. That said, the workaround that will be least complicated is still more tedious than I think it needs to me (and I can't get the sweep function to work in my favour here). Hope to see this feature sometime soon!
  • Options
    brucebartlettbrucebartlett Member, OS Professional, Mentor, User Group Leader Posts: 2,137 PRO
    erik_st_gelais said:
    I'm brand new to OnShape and I'm already looking for this feature. My very first drawing, designing a step stool. I see the above comment regarding simplicity vs robustness, and I certainly appreciate how easy it is to learn the basics. That said, the workaround that will be least complicated is still more tedious than I think it needs to me (and I can't get the sweep function to work in my favour here). Hope to see this feature sometime soon!
    I am still missing this.  Make sure you vote to get this included.  
    Engineer ı Product Designer ı Onshape Consulting Partner
    Twitter: @onshapetricks  & @babart1977   
Sign In or Register to comment.

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Sign In

Categories

Vanilla Forums