Offset problem inwards a multi point sketch.

I have created a clark-y profile to make wing spars using "Profile Generator".

When I have extruded the suface I want to make an offset inwards to create a thin frame.
I get an error message, see picture one. How can I get around this?
Offset outwards, no problems, see picture two.
Without extrude, picture three.
What is it that I did wrong?

one.png two.png three.png

Answers

  • S1mon
    S1mon Member Posts: 4,637 PRO

    I would highly recommend using the HVAF airfoil generator instead:

    https://www.onshape.com/it/blog/streamlining-airfoil-design-custom-features

    It will create smoother curves which will cause fewer issues.

    Offsetting outwards with a convex shape is almost always easy. Offsetting inwards often causes issues either because there are areas with unexpectedly higher curvature or things need to be intersected in a weird way. If you check the curvature using Shift-C and turn on the minimum radius option, you'll be able to see where there might be issues.

    Simon Gatrall | Product Development, Engineering, Design, Onshape | Ex- IDEO, PCH, Unagi, Carbon | LinkedIn

  • eric_pesty
    eric_pesty Member, pcbaevp Posts: 2,941 PRO

    Also, as a general rule, offsetting surfaces is more robust than offsetting sketch entities. So if you already have a surface you are more likely to be able to offset that instead of the sketch.

    Also, it seems like you should be able to use a "thin extrude" from the sketch or a "thicken" of the surface

  • robert_persson875
    robert_persson875 Member Posts: 4 ✭

    Thank's for the answers. I tried thin extrude but it didn't work, I also tried thicken but I had no success with that either.
    I simply dropped my design and did it another way.