Welcome to the Onshape forum! Ask questions and join in the discussions about everything Onshape.

First time visiting? Here are some places to start:

  1. Looking for a certain topic? Check out the categories filter or use Search (upper right).
  2. Need support? Ask a question to our Community Support category.
  3. Please submit support tickets for bugs but you can request improvements in the Product Feedback category.
  4. Be respectful, on topic and if you see a problem, Flag it.

If you would like to contact our Community Manager personally, feel free to send a private message or an email.

How can I make an embossment that ist cut by the edge of the part?

oliver_august
oliver_august Member, pcbaevp Posts: 32 PRO
edited August 18 in Community Support

I have to transfer a sheet metal part from SolidWorks to Onshape.
The part has several embosses, some of them cut by the edge of the part.
In SolidWorks there is no real problem - it adds material beyond the edge when you add the embossment, you cut it off afterwards - problem solved.

SolidWorks:

Embossing_SW_01.JPG Embossing_SW.JPG

Working with Onshape, no matter what I try, nothing works…

If I try to add the embossment like in the first picture, the embossments that cut the edge aren´t added at all, you get errors shown etc.

If I add material, so that the embosses don´t cut the edge, I can add them, no problem.

But if I cut this material off afterwards, the embosses are removed and are shown as errors, doesn´t work either.

Onshape:

Embossing_OS_extra_material.JPG

Embossing_OS_extra_material_cut_off.JPG


I´m used to having to use workarounds to make things work in Onshape, but this time I don´t know what to try in addition to get a part that looks like it should and leads to a correct flat pattern.

I suppose you can make special embosses only for this part or something like that, but that can´t be a serious solution, wasting too much time.

Can anyone help?

Tagged:

Answers

  • Derek_Van_Allen_BD
    Derek_Van_Allen_BD Member Posts: 1,166 PRO

    I believe this is a hard limitation with the tool registration functions in the engine that disallow form features to extend past the sheet boundaries of a given sheet metal surface body. I've experimented with trying to modify the form tool to work on non-planar faces and across bends but all of these attempts were unsuccessful. @lana would know best though.

  • lana
    lana Onshape Employees Posts: 782 image

    That is indeed a current limitation of sheet metal Form feature . You can remove the extra material after Finish sheet metal - then it is all baked into 3d, but it will remain in flat pattern.

  • oliver_august
    oliver_august Member, pcbaevp Posts: 32 PRO

    Yes, making the 3D model work is not a real problem, that works comparably good as in SolidWorks.
    But we also need a DXF to manufacture the part.
    As we obviously have to deal with this flaw indefinitely we tried to find a workaround for the DXF.
    It´s too time-consuming and hand-knitted for my liking, but it works.

    Beginnig at the very start, first you have to add enough material to make the embossment work at all:

    Embossing_001.JPG

    Then you can do the forming of the sheet metal:

    Embossing_002.JPG

    After that you can finish the sheet metal part (that´s a sheet metal feature) and cut off the surplus material like you would do in any other part studio:

    Embossing_003.JPG

    Btw: Just look for the red points in the following images!

    Now you generate a DXF from the flat pattern of this sheet metal part.
    Of course this flat pattern isn´t correct, that´s what we´re talking about here:

    Embossing_01.JPG

    Choose what should be included in this DXF:

    Embossing_02.JPG

    Now yout get the DXF with the unwanted bulges:

    Embossing_03.JPG

    Create a new part studio:

    Embossing_04.JPG

    Start a new sketch.
    Click the "DXF" icon and choose insert DXF or DWG:

    Embossing_055.JPG

    Choose the DXF with the unwanted bulges:

    Embossing_06.JPG

    This way you got a new sketch derived from the DXF:

    Embossing_07.JPG

    Now you can edit the unwanted bulges:

    Embossing_08.JPG

    Do a right click on the sketch and choose export as DXF / DWG:

    Embossing_09.JPG

    Now you got a DXF that looks like your part in real life - beside the fact that the hole in the embossment is still missing, only the bend lines are shown:

    Embossing_10.JPG

    If you want to make a drawing of the flat pattern, you have to generate an additional part studio, import this edited DXF (see above) and make a solid part of it.
    Of course all lines that depict bend lines etc. have to be converted into discontinuous lines before.
    And if these bend lines should be shown in the drawing, you have to display the sketch in addition to the part.
    Of course you have to add the bend lettering (up or down, radius, bending angle) manually now.
    Best way in my opinion to add the right values is to generate a depiciton from the original flat pattern and put it beside the drawing sheet as a template for the hand-knitted edited version.
    This way you can also check if there were changes to the part when you open the drawing in the future.
    Because I don´t think this drawing will update automatically…