Loft failure when I use a third guide

Trying to run this loft with two connected profiles and two guides. To get a better shape, I added a third guide and I get this failure. All corners and curve ends are coincidented. Any suiggestions?

Loft failure 01.png Loft failure 02.png
Tagged:

Best Answers

  • MDesign
    MDesign Member Posts: 1,472 PRO
    Answer ✓

    Pretty sure your coincident on the middle curve is incorrect.

  • Matt_Shields
    Matt_Shields Member, Onshape Employees Posts: 1,006 PRO
    Answer ✓

    Two tips:
    1. Create a surface first, then enclose.
    2. Use the curves you're using for guides as profiles and vice versa.

    image.png
  • rick_randall
    rick_randall Member Posts: 443 ✭✭✭
    Answer ✓

    @john_kukovich - Your situation is where the "pierce " command really shines, I prefer it over coincident, for most guide curve uses - it just feels more robust when connecting profiles in 3D space.

Answers

  • Matt_Shields
    Matt_Shields Member, Onshape Employees Posts: 1,006 PRO

    It would help if you made the document public and shared the link here.

  • john_kukovich
    john_kukovich Member Posts: 6 PRO

    Thank you Matt, I forgot to link the model. I tried again by simplifying my guide curves, but still can't seem to get it to work.

    https://cad.onshape.com/documents/ded610b37b912937883ff55e/w/f10e9a5811b29867546d7be7/e/c2886052a2cd2b621e9dcd1e

  • MDesign
    MDesign Member Posts: 1,472 PRO
    Answer ✓

    Pretty sure your coincident on the middle curve is incorrect.

  • john_kukovich
    john_kukovich Member Posts: 6 PRO

    Thank you! That fixed that new issue, now back to the original issue in my first images. That one corner still giving me trouble.

  • Matt_Shields
    Matt_Shields Member, Onshape Employees Posts: 1,006 PRO
    Answer ✓

    Two tips:
    1. Create a surface first, then enclose.
    2. Use the curves you're using for guides as profiles and vice versa.

    image.png
  • rick_randall
    rick_randall Member Posts: 443 ✭✭✭
    Answer ✓

    @john_kukovich - Your situation is where the "pierce " command really shines, I prefer it over coincident, for most guide curve uses - it just feels more robust when connecting profiles in 3D space.

  • john_kukovich
    john_kukovich Member Posts: 6 PRO

    Thank you all for your help! A combination of these made it work.