We have a request for doing a git-like pull request. The ability to modify a copy of a public and request it to merge back is a complex workflow but we completely understand th benefit. I can add you to the request if you like.
Welcome to the Onshape forum! Ask questions and join in the discussions about everything Onshape.
First time visiting? Here are some places to start:- Looking for a certain topic? Check out the categories filter or use Search (upper right).
- Need support? Ask a question to our Community Support category.
- Please submit support tickets for bugs but you can request improvements in the Product Feedback category.
- Be respectful, on topic and if you see a problem, Flag it.
If you would like to contact our Community Manager personally, feel free to send a private message or an email.
Options
Take temporary control of document in forum. (To ask for or offer help in forum)
owen_sparks
Member, Developers Posts: 2,660 PRO
Hi folks.
This forum seems a great resource with a whole bunch of helpful people frequenting it. (Thanks for that BTW)
A suggestion for the future. I wonder if the methods used to ask for, and offer up help in the forums could be made a little easier?
I see quite a lot of this scenario on the forums:-
(Poster) I'd like some help doing xyz please.
(Reply) Sure, happy to help but I'm not quite sure what you mean, can you post a screen grab?
(Poster) Here you go...
(Reply) Ah, I see. Can you post a public copy of your document and I'll try something for you?
(Poster) I've made it public it's called "dfhsdjfj"
(Reply) Sorry I can't find "dhsdjfj" can you post a hyperlink to the url?
(Poster) ...
What I'd like to suggest is something along these lines
(a) Poster is stuck whilst working in their document so they hit a "Please help me" button from within the partstudio. A dialog comes up asking for a brief explanation of the issue. A post is then automatically generated on the forum. A revision or public copy of the doc is also automatically created.
(b) Helper. Someone in the forum sees the post and is available / willing to help. They can then click "take control of doc" from the forum post and immediately have the document open for editing in a partstudio. They do their thing and add a comment when done. Forum updates.
(c) Poster can accept changes and have it merge to their doc or reject to keep original.
(d) Was sort of joking with this bit but perhaps not. Optional check box along with "mark question answered" to offer 50 cents via paypal to a designated charity of the "helper".
Just thinking out loud.
Owen S.
This forum seems a great resource with a whole bunch of helpful people frequenting it. (Thanks for that BTW)
A suggestion for the future. I wonder if the methods used to ask for, and offer up help in the forums could be made a little easier?
I see quite a lot of this scenario on the forums:-
(Poster) I'd like some help doing xyz please.
(Reply) Sure, happy to help but I'm not quite sure what you mean, can you post a screen grab?
(Poster) Here you go...
(Reply) Ah, I see. Can you post a public copy of your document and I'll try something for you?
(Poster) I've made it public it's called "dfhsdjfj"
(Reply) Sorry I can't find "dhsdjfj" can you post a hyperlink to the url?
(Poster) ...
What I'd like to suggest is something along these lines
(a) Poster is stuck whilst working in their document so they hit a "Please help me" button from within the partstudio. A dialog comes up asking for a brief explanation of the issue. A post is then automatically generated on the forum. A revision or public copy of the doc is also automatically created.
(b) Helper. Someone in the forum sees the post and is available / willing to help. They can then click "take control of doc" from the forum post and immediately have the document open for editing in a partstudio. They do their thing and add a comment when done. Forum updates.
(c) Poster can accept changes and have it merge to their doc or reject to keep original.
(d) Was sort of joking with this bit but perhaps not. Optional check box along with "mark question answered" to offer 50 cents via paypal to a designated charity of the "helper".
Just thinking out loud.
Owen S.
Business Systems and Configuration Controller
HWM-Water Ltd
HWM-Water Ltd
2
Best Answer
-
Options
lougallo
Member, Moderator, Onshape Employees, Developers Posts: 2,001 
Lou Gallo / PD/UX - Support - Community / Onshape, Inc.5
Answers
Ta, Owen S
HWM-Water Ltd