drawing - dimension not correct

wolfgang_maier

Hello,

i have a door frame with hinges 497.5 mm away from the edge. When i create a drawing and show the distance of the hinge, Onshape shows 351mm. What am i doing wrong?

Link to my document:
https://cad.onshape.com/documents/c6340dbcf74fde9791d7d34e/w/5ee994347b6b0a1748d30ef6/e/26d8845e42914aec02e5d9c3

bruce_williams

I do not think Onshape supports dimensions in oblique views.  Note all the dimensions are incorrect in iso view.  The section view shows correctly.

bruce_williams

I do not think Onshape supports dimensions in oblique views.  Note all the dimensions are incorrect in iso view.  The section view shows correctly.

mr_deek

Hello, 

I would say the 'Accepted' diagnosis is incorrect. A measurement is absolute, to consider any other value based on a view is absurd. 


I may suggest this phrasing ... and further direction ...

Not supported = Can perform the action. Resulting action provides an Error notification ( or no action / no result / out of scope of product ). 
Bug = Can perform the action. Resulting action is incorrect.

Bug(s) should be corrected in the product as they are misleading and incorrect.

Thank you.

NikNYC

Onshape already devolving into a cult? Downvotes against rational criticism?
Yup!

owen_sparks

nik_willmore said:

Onshape already devolving into a cult? Downvotes against rational criticism?
Yup!

I agree; both with your terminology / analysis of the issue above and the absurdity of down-voting such a comment.  On behalf of the community "Sorry".  For what it's worth it's not normally like that here.

Owen S.

bruce_williams

 I agree @mr_deek makes a good case for terminology.  Thanks for those definitions.

owen_sparks

Oh look a couple of those down-votes have gone away

victor_mendoza099

I’m not a pro but it is sad that dimensions on isometric views on OS are wrong. Isometric drawings are by far more compelling that any ortho view so any info associated to that kind geometric representation should not be misleading as it is on current OS drawings.

victor_mendoza099

.. and OS team should not wait a democracy-style vote to fix something that is wrong.

erik_hjertholm

I am still experiencing this in 2024! How is this not fixed yet? This is an absolute show stopper when it comes to select this as a professional cad tool. In the part studio, the selected dimension is 5000mm, while in the drawing it is 4506.94mm. Is this even on the roadmap to fix?

majkl_majkl457

I was just about to write about the same Onshape behaviour. This is very… sad… and bizarre "feature" of any CAD system.

MDesign

How to build things has been done in 2d since the beginning.. Dimensions in 3D unfortunately isn't the norm…. yet. I do this in other software on my other projects. Definately would utilize it in OS if it was done well and makes life easy.

james_sedgwick

Confirmed still an issue, if the feature is there it should work correctly.

Silently placing incorrect dimensions into drawings is crazy, and the length of time this has gone without a fix is negligent. It'll end up costing someone one day, if it hasn't already.

david_kingsbury117

Just ran into this on my first drawing - I thought I was going insane 😅

nick_papageorge_dayjob

Can Creo do this today? I stopped using it in 2021 after switching to OS. I don't believe it could then.

MDesign

Interesting that I can do 3d dimensions on views like this in an architectural program like Revit but not in Onshape. Granted its a much more mature program I believe.

HARDWOODFP_ENGINEERING

this is such a basic thing OnShape is still missing. There are posts of people complaining about this for several years ad still no fix. It`s frustrating. SolidWorks and I`d guess all other major cad systems let you add dimensions to 3d views.