Having trouble getting two parts to become one due to compound angles

joe_fisher391
joe_fisher391 Member Posts: 13 ✭

First, the document: https://cad.onshape.com/documents/f790c4df8cc85d2b9b7c3dec/w/88b9d6ea8cf4e90bee3c2489/e/e747193ea9e06b13514b1209

I'm making a part that snaps onto an angled rod with a tray attached to it.

image.png

image.png

I made the part with a sketch in the top plane, then extruded down using the rod as the direction.

image.png

And then I made the tray on the same plane and also extruded it down.

image.png

But when I tried to merge them, turns out they don't intersect. Because the clip extrusion is angled, the bottom pulls away from the face of the tray, which is more clear if I extrude the tray to the same depth as the clip and look at it from the bottom:

image.png

So I can fudge it by making the clip longer so it extends inside the tray, but it's not a great solution and there must be a better way to get those faces to meet.

image.png

Is there a tool or a way to look at this that I'm missing here?

Answers

  • robert_scott_jr_
    robert_scott_jr_ Member Posts: 948 ✭✭✭

    Hey Joe. Try extruding the face of part 2 using Up to face as the end type and the face of part 4 as the face to extrude to. - Scotty

  • joe_fisher391
    joe_fisher391 Member Posts: 13 ✭

    Thanks for the suggestion, Scotty. Today I learned that you can extrude existing faces!

    Sadly though, I can't select the faces that I want to extrude. Maybe because they touch at the top edge?

    I can select these two faces, but I can't select the one that faces the dark blue part. Nor can I select the face on the side of the blue part that faces the gray one.

    image.png

    image.png
  • joe_fisher391
    joe_fisher391 Member Posts: 13 ✭

    It does seem like Move Boundary would do exactly what I want, but I can't select any surfaces. I've tried two different sketches and none of my surfaces or edges are selectable.

    image.png
  • robert_scott_jr_
    robert_scott_jr_ Member Posts: 948 ✭✭✭

    Hey Joe. The reason that face can't be selected is because it is not planar (flat). Back in Sketch 2, the element that created that face is a curve. Changing that to a line allows the face to be selected.

    The method I used to get parts 3 & 4 to mate nicely was to change the curve to a line and use Move Face to have part 4 extend into part 3. I then created a sketch on the top surface of part 3 and used the Use tool to capture the edge of part 3. The resulting sketch element was used to create a surface that was then used to Split part 4. A bit of a complicated approach. Perhaps someone can chime in with a simpler way. - Scotty

    Document

  • EvanReese
    EvanReese Member, Mentor Posts: 3,096 PRO

    How about using Replace Face on the grey face and replacing it with the blue face?

    Evan Reese
    The Onsherpa | Reach peak Onshape productivity
    www.theonsherpa.com
  • Nameorus
    Nameorus Member Posts: 65 EDU
    edited November 12

    I fixed it but your workflow is kinda weird:

    Copy