worldToPlane() gives inconsistent location?

alan_1

I am trying to get a 2D point on a surface that I can then extrude.  In this example, I am using a line's endpoint and attempting to extrude a circle with that point as its center.  it works in one orientation, but when I switch orientations it either moves the extrude or fails completely (extrude error).  In my testing, the line is drawn on a flat surface and is well within the interior of that surface.  The surface is of a simple XYZ rectangular block.  Think rectangle in "top" plane then extrude.  So we're not talking non-90-degree angles at the moment.
Here's the code snippet.
I figure I'm misusing something, but not quite sure what the misuse is.

            var endpoints = evaluateQuery(context, qVertexAdjacent(line, EntityType.VERTEX));

            var A is Vector = evVertexPoint(context, { "vertex" : endpoints[0] });

            var aInPlane = worldToPlane(sketchPlane, A);

            var Avec = vector(aInPlane[0], aInPlane[1]);

            var circleB = skCircle(sketch1, "circleA" ~ index, {

                "center" : Avec,

                "radius" : definition.width / 2

            });

            skSolve(sketch1);

            var exid = id + ("extrude1" ~ index);

            extrude(context, exid, {

                    "entities" : qSketchRegion(sketchid),

                    "endBound" : BoundingType.UP_TO_BODY,

                    "depth" : (definition.height + 1 * meter),

                    "endBoundEntityBody" : definition.targetBody,

                    "operationType" : NewBodyOperationType.ADD,

                    "defaultScope" : false,

                    "booleanScope" : definition.targetBody,

                    "oppositeDirection" : true

            });

ilya_baran

I am going to guess you're using newSketch to create the sketch (that part of your code is actually missing) -- that gives you pretty poor control over the sketch orientation and origin.  For FS, I recommend using newSketchOnPlane instead and passing in the plane.  See https://cad.onshape.com/FsDoc/library.html#module-sketch.fs

alan_1

I have been using a method from the FeatureScript Snap Hook example.  It looks similar to this:

            var sketchPlane = evOwnerSketchPlane(context, { "entity" : endpoints[0] });

            var topPlane = plane(sketchPlane.origin +  (definition.height) * sketchPlane.normal, sketchPlane.normal);

            var sketchid = id + ("sketch1" ~ index);

            var sketch1 = newSketchOnPlane(context, sketchid, { "sketchPlane" : topPlane });

I suspect that somewhere in this code snippet the orientation gets flipped.  Perhaps the use of plane().  I tried using sketchPlane instead of topPlane and have solved my issue.

ilya_baran

Ah I think I see -- you're specifying topPlane by a point and normal, so the reference (x axis in the plane) is getting automatically set instead of being set from sketchPlane.  Pass sketchPlane.x as the third argument to plane and that should solve your problem.