Entities selection priority

konstantin_shiriazdanov · February 2018

Recently i notices that some of my FS and standart features suddenly started to only allow Entities of body type if the input field filter has this option among other entity types like faces. This is exactly not how it worked before, and i liked prevous behavior better. Was this intentional global change or it only with me?

Image: https://us.v-cdn.net/5022071/uploads/editor/lc/6kylbon9usck.gif

Evan · February 2018

This was intentional change that was introduced in an effort to improve the selection experience around the split feature. However, there have been enough adversely affected features in other areas that we will be reverting to the old behavior in the next release.

In the meantime, you can use the "Select other" command to select individual entities.

MBartlett21 · February 2018

Evan said:

This was intentional change that was introduced in an effort to improve the selection experience around the split feature. However, there have been enough adversely affected features in other areas that we will be reverting to the old behavior in the next release.

In the meantime, you can use the "Select other" command to select individual entities.

When will the next release come?

Jake_Rosenfeld · February 2018

@mbartlett21

Releases come approximately every three weeks.

MBartlett21 · February 2018

@Jake_Rosenfeld

That will mean I can remove some selection boxes in my feature here.

michał_1 · February 2018

That seems to affect also picking an edge in loft (when lofting surfaces)... akward

michał_1 · February 2018

Image: https://us.v-cdn.net/5022071/uploads/editor/id/drdv7yb5jrch.gif

konstantin_shiriazdanov · February 2018

it works so for all bodies - solid, sheet or wire. entities of body type got the highest priority. possibly priority control could be based on filter order and thus it could be adjusted transparently for each feature, instead of this hidden magic

michał_1 · February 2018

Now you need to be a jedi to make Onshape work.

mahir · February 2018

michał_1 said:

Now you need to be a jedi to make Onshape work.

Pick body or do not pick body. There is no edge.

MBartlett21 · March 2018

konstantin_shiriazdanov said:

it works so for all bodies - solid, sheet or wire. entities of body type got the highest priority. possibly priority control could be based on filter order and thus it could be adjusted transparently for each feature, instead of this hidden magic

This should probably be configured in a UIHint:

what i think the code should look like:

annotation { "Name" : "Example Query", "Filter" : EntityType.FACE && EntityType.BODY, "UIHint" : "PRIORITY_USING_FILTER" }
definition.exampleQuery is Query;

kevin_o_toole_1 · March 2018

@mbartlett21 We agree.

For the upcoming release, we are simply reverting back to the old behavior for all custom features, so the issues described here will be fixed. However, if/when we want FS writers to control this, we'll use an explicit UIHint rather than implicitly encoding the priority via filter order.

Jake_Rosenfeld · March 2018

This should be fixed now

Entities selection priority

Comments

Categories