Welcome to the Onshape forum! Ask questions and join in the discussions about everything Onshape.
First time visiting? Here are some places to start:- Looking for a certain topic? Check out the categories filter or use Search (upper right).
- Need support? Ask a question to our Community Support category.
- Please submit support tickets for bugs but you can request improvements in the Product Feedback category.
- Be respectful, on topic and if you see a problem, Flag it.
If you would like to contact our Community Manager personally, feel free to send a private message or an email.
curve in PDF file seems to have a ton of unneeded points
Marc_Miller
Member Posts: 111 ✭✭✭
I opened a PDF file up in some vector software and discovered that a simple curve had a ton of points, I was quite surprised by this since the shape should only need 7 points. Is there a reason Onshape seems to be exporting curves like this, or a way to export a "simplified" curve?
I have attached an Onshape PDF drawing with a few simple shapes (exported from this file).
The top circle has what I would expect, just four points.
The other curves have a huge number of points! This "fat blue line" is really a ton of points all highlighted from a window select. If I zoom way way in I eventually can see the individual points.
This is what I was expecting to see, just 7 points.
(I drew this as a circle and a rectangle and combined/merged them in the vector software Affinity Designer.)
I have attached an Onshape PDF drawing with a few simple shapes (exported from this file).
The top circle has what I would expect, just four points.
The other curves have a huge number of points! This "fat blue line" is really a ton of points all highlighted from a window select. If I zoom way way in I eventually can see the individual points.
This is what I was expecting to see, just 7 points.
(I drew this as a circle and a rectangle and combined/merged them in the vector software Affinity Designer.)
Tagged:
1
Answers
-
PDF output is for viewing and printing, not vector editing, so we are just converting the drawing graphics as-is (a circle in computer graphics is just a polyline).Senior Director, Technical Services, EMEA0
-
Ok, thank you @NeilCooke
We are sending PDF drawings to a laser cutter which is why I had noticed this in the first place. Sometimes not ideal with all those extra points. But I totally understand from Onshape's perspective that is probably not something you would suggest or expect a user to be doing with PDF drawings.
0 -
If sending to a laser cutter, perhaps exporting as DXF would be a better option.2
-
@mahir I can do (and have done) that, but it's a Glowforge laser cutter and for whatever reason the Glowforge company decided they don't want to support DXF. Something about it's not a standardized enough format to support. What the heck, right?
So if I export a DXF I need an intermediate step (i'm using Inkscape) to open the DXF and save as an SVG for the laser. Or if I export as PDF I have now discovered I can open it in Affinity Designer, do a Select All and run a "smooth curve" command that does a nice job of optimizing the nodes, and then save as PDF or SVG for the laser. I was, of course, just hoping avoid the intermediate step each time.
0 -
What about using a cloud conversion tool for that intermediate step? (e.g. https://convertio.co/dxf-svg/)
Maybe that produces nice nodes...0 -
Thank you @fnxf that's a good idea I will check out a bit more and keep in mind.
0 -
I've confirmed that when exporting as DXF and then opening in Inkscape you don't get all the extra points. And I suspect that if then converted to PDF via Inkscape that the extra points wouldn't be there either if using the appropriate conversion settings... maybe.0
