Render Battle #2 is here!

Axel_Kollmenter · March 2023

Thank you Sebastian

SethF · March 2023

MichaelPascoe said:

Can I vote for this one?

MichaelPascoe · March 2023

@SethF lol a single branch

sure, why not!

I really wish that one would have worked. After doing some more testing, the privatives were fine up into the millions for my simplified tree studio. So perhaps the issue was the number of mate connectors and instances. I may be able to get that to work still if I used composite parts instead of individual bristles with mate connectors. It's hard to test because it takes quite a bit of effort and then all of a sudden, BOOM, your studio is overloaded and bogged down. The rate is exponential I think from previous tests. But there is a lot going on, there are so many different variables affecting it. Part qty, mate connectors, instances, privatives, etc...

Here are the results for a Regen Sim test I did a while back related to privatives in a part studio:

Image: https://us.v-cdn.net/5022071/uploads/editor/od/11gn1md9k0ri.jpg

MichaelPascoe · March 2023

Since we are on page 3 of this forum topic, I'll post another reminder for others who are reading:

Voting is now OPEN for all Onshape forum users!

Voting end date is March 8th.

It's up to YOU! Comment below about which render you think was the most epic Christmas tree.

More forum users voting = more fun

Axel_Kollmenter · March 2023

@MichaelPascoe try placing the branches into individual sub-assemblies and then grouping them together. Maybe that works better

René_Sartorio · March 2023

+1 for @Axel_Kollmenter

oliver_august · March 2023

I like the metallic red and gold in the rendering of @Axel_Kollmenter

MichaelPascoe · March 2023

Thanks @René_Sartorio & @oliver_august for the participation! This is turning out to be a fantastic render battle.

MichaelPascoe · March 2023

We have quite the turn out. Check out these results!

Results:

+4 @Axel_Kollmenter's Floating ornament tree
+3 @emagdalenaC2i's Ladder tree
+4 @MichaelPascoe's Traditional tree
+1 @MichaelPascoe's Lone branch

It was almost a 3 way tie! Still a two way tie between @Axel_Kollmenter and myself. Cool, how should we settle this? Or just leave it a tie?

bryan_lagrange · March 2023

You settle this with a Too Tall Toby CAD speed render battle!

Axel_Kollmenter · March 2023

Or we compare the current upvotes on the renders

MichaelPascoe · March 2023

Both great ideas!

I like the upvote idea for settling ties. Genius.

bryan_lagrange · March 2023

Best render on this Onshape Logo sheet metal part:

I'll display the winner at the upcoming sheet metal user group meeting: (Click named views: logo view to put it into logo perspective)

https://cad.onshape.com/documents/b1a1073b83a089710333ef27/w/67f8575744dce6ae1ef52a34/e/87380b8f2017d12827cb309f

Image: https://us.v-cdn.net/5022071/uploads/editor/27/uakt3xzww24h.png

MichaelPascoe · March 2023

You going to make that? That is legit.

MichaelPascoe · March 2023

Render Battle #2

Results:

@Axel_Kollmenter's Floating ornament tree - 4 votes
@MichaelPascoe's Traditional tree - 4 votes
@emagdalenaC2i's Ladder tree - 3 votes
@MichaelPascoe's Lone branch - 1 vote

Tie breaker:

Render with the most thumbs ups breaks the tie.

And the winner is

:drum roll: 🥁🥁🥁

@Axel_Kollmenter!

Congrats Axel!
As a reward, you will be noted in all future render battles in the Render Battle Hall of Fame list.

Image: https://us.v-cdn.net/5022071/uploads/editor/86/2c5pac6tu952.gif

bryan_lagrange · March 2023

I could maybe make it in paper.

richard_doyle · March 2023

Congratulations to @Axel_Kollmenter and thanks to everyone who didn't vote for my render. It's made me more determined to up my game

Richard

bryan_lagrange · March 2023

Congrats @Axel_Kollmenter

Axel_Kollmenter · March 2023

Thank you all for your voting

super Happy. Congrats to every other with a rendering. There are all great!

René_Sartorio · April 2023

bryan_lagrange said:

Best render on this Onshape Logo sheet metal part:

I'll display the winner at the upcoming sheet metal user group meeting: (Click named views: logo view to put it into logo perspective)

https://cad.onshape.com/documents/b1a1073b83a089710333ef27/w/67f8575744dce6ae1ef52a34/e/87380b8f2017d12827cb309f

I like the idea.
The focus should be on the rendering itself.
I would specify views.
So all render experts can show their render skills.

MichaelPascoe · April 2023

Great ideas. Once Render Battle #3 is finished, we can mix it up a bit for Render Battle #4.
I'm worried I may end up being the only participant for RB#3

Render Battle #2 is here!

Answers

Voting is now OPEN for all Onshape forum users!

Results:

Render Battle #2

Results:

Tie breaker:

And the winner is

@Axel_Kollmenter!

Howdy, Stranger!

Quick Links

Categories